1834 Asa Beck

1835 Israel Lewis

1836 Isaac Welch

1837 Asa Beck & John Newell

1838 Hezekiah Smith

1839 Enoch Wood & Wesley Dorsey

1840 Miles Huffaker & Jonas Belotte

1841 Jonas Belotte

1842 Daniel F. Stright (w/New Augusta Church)

1843 John Myers

1844-1845 R. H. Calvert

1846 Thomas Brown

1847 Herman Badley

1848-1849 Thomas Bartlett

1850 Michael Johnson

1851 Michael Johnson & F. A. Hardin

1852 Harrison Burgess

1853 Harrison Burgess & C. B. Heath

1854 Joseph Marsee & J. F. McDaniel

1855 Joseph Marsee & Griffith Morgan

1856 Ferris Pierce & Griffith Morgan

1857 Hezekiah Smith & Ferris Pierce

1858 Charles Brooke & Francis Pavey

1859 Charles Brooke & Charles Smith

1860 Jacob Cozad & J. A. Clearwater

1861 Luther Taylor & H. N. Ornbaun

1862 Luther Taylor

1863 George Warner

1864 John DeMotte

1865-1866 Herman B. Ball

1867 Herman B. Ball & John M. Stafford

1868-1869 Oliver Haskell

1870 W. M. Farley & Elbert Dille

1871 Samuel Colvin & Jas. M. Beard

1872 Henry Buchtel (6 months)

1872 Daniel Risher (6 months)

1873-1875 Elijah Lawhon

1876-1877 Francis Cox

1878-1879 John Newhouse

1880 Joseph Cullon, J. Matthews & J. Shell

1881 Joseph Cullon

1882-1884 John McDaniel

1885-1886 David McClain

1887 Larkin Hurt

1888 Thomas Webb

1889 John C. Reeve

1890-1891 A. A. Hendrix

1893-1894 J. H. Rayle

1895 A. N. Cave

1896 M. V. Brown

1897-1898 E. G. Pelley

1899 W. G. Vessels

1900-1901 W. F. Clark

1902-1904 E. W. Strecker

1905-1909 H. C. Weston

1910-1913 A. P. DeLong

1914-1915 G. L. Rulison

1916-1918 Israel Hatton

1919-1921 O. P. Paxon

1922 W. L. Absher

1923-1926 W. W. Clouse

1927-1932 Wayne M. Nicely

1933-1935 Earl Heimburger

1936-1938 Horace McBride

1939-1940 Merline Burgette

1941-1945 Edward Byrd (or James Everett Byrd)

1946-1947 Chester Imhousen

1948 Henry Profitt

1949-1953 Don Weaver

1954 Scott Browning

1955-1957 Jack Fitzgerald

1958-1959 William Tressler

1960 Louis D. Balsley

1961 Willard R. Fair

1962-1963 Glenn Clarkson

1964-1965 Ronald Dixon

1966 Jack Frick

1967-1968 Ron Rick

1969 Jim Powell

1970-1971 Tom W. Terrell

1972-1973 Wayne Trevatham

1974-1976 Terry Campbell (Retired-Greenfield)

1977-1978 William Murphy

1979-1982 Mark Dodd

1982-1984 David Campbell

1984 (4 months) Robert Phillips

1984-1996 James W. Hertel Sr. (Retired)

1997-1999 Wayne Patton (Retired-Carmel)

2000 Bonnie Plybon

2001-2005 Phillip Lewis (Retired- Indianapolis/Georgia)

2005-2005 Jim Miller

2005-2008 Wayne Patton & Jim Miller

2008-2017 Jim Miller (Retired-Indianapolis)

2017-2020 Gina Kirkland

2020-2022 Perry Montgomery (Full 7-1-22)

2022-2025 Jim Ewing

2025-Present Krista Price